The Complete List of Reward Ideas for your School Store

Posted by:
Aubrie Chaillet
4 minute read

What to Stock in your School Store? 

If you're looking to refresh your school store, or for more PBIS incentive ideas to motivate your students, you're in the right place! Here is your complete list of free and low cost reward ideas, broken down by grade level. 

School Store and Rewards

Reward Ideas for Elementary School

Free Reward Ideas:

  1. Extra Recess Time 
  2. Line Leader for the Day 
  3. Lunch with the Teacher
  4. Choose a Classroom Game
  5. Bookmarks – Customizing with a student’s name and even laminating at school is a great DIY option.
  6. Positive Note Home
  7. Classroom DJ for a Day
  8. Sit by a Friend
  9. Extra Computer Time
  10. Reading Buddy Time
  11. Classroom Helper for a Day – Pro Tip: Designate a special desk for this purpose somewhere close to you for that student to sit for the day!
  12. Library Pass
  13. Pick a Book for the Class to Read
  14. Show-and-Tell Time – This is great for students who have been really excited to talk about a new book or toy that they have received.
  15. Read the Morning Announcements
  16. Die your Principal’s Hair Blue 
  17. Stinky Feet Shoes off in class, as long as it’s not after recess ;) 
  18. Teach a Lesson to the Class
  19. Chalk at Recess
  20. Take a 2 Minute Vacation – Pro Tip: Sometimes I slide this coupon to a student who needs a quick break to cool off. The other students just assume he or she bought it from the store so they are not being called out!
  21. Pie your Teacher in the Face 
  22. Use a Comfy Chair for the Day 
  23. Tell a (pre-approved) Joke Over the Intercom 
  24. Tug of War with the Teachers 

Low Cost Reward Ideas: 

  1. Desk Pets – Buying fun animal and plant shaped mini-erasers on Amazon in bulk keeps your store stocked for a while!
  2. Fancy Pencils
  3. Smelly Markers
  4. Stickers
  5. Temporary Tattoos
  6. Croc Charms/Jibbitz – This variety pack on Amazon has something for everyone!
  7. Keychains
  8. Bubbles
  9. Finger Puppets or Tech Decks
  10. Snacks and Candy – Ring Pops and Takis are the biggest hit for my 5th graders!
  11. Play-Doh
  12. Small Action Figure or Animal Figurines
Croc Charms and Jibbitz for School Store

Reward Ideas for Middle School

Free Reward Ideas:

  1. Homework Pass
  2. Extended Deadline on an Assignment
  3. Free Choice Seating – Make sure to outline expectations if students are choosing to sit with friends, or provide flex seating like comfy chairs to choose from!
  4. Skip a Quiz Pass
  5. Positive Note Home
  6. Classroom Helper for a Day – Pro Tip: Set aside special days, such as lab days if for a science class, or station days for other subjects, and have the student be a “Teacher’s Assistant” and be tasked with helping other students.
  7. Class Outdoors
  8. Free Time
  9. Classroom DJ for a Day
  10. Dress Down Day Pass – If your school doesn't have uniforms but has rules on wearing hats, crocs, etc., this can also apply- just be sure to clear it with admin first!
  11. Skip the Odd Numbers on an Assignment
  12. Lead a Class Discussion – Pro Tip: Call the reward Discussion Leader and have that student be able to pick who to call on and have a list of questions that need to be asked and answered! 
  13. Choose the Classroom Activity
  14. Extra Free Time on Computer 
  15. Free Peak at an Upcoming Assignment

Low Cost Reward Ideas:

  1. Gel Pens
  2. Stylish Notebooks
  3. Bracelets – DIY friendship bracelet making kits by buying embroidery thread in bulk. 
  4. Scrunchies & Hair Ties
  5. Mini Posters
  6. Stickers
  7. Lanyards & ID Badge Holders
  8. Snacks – Takis and soda are always a hit. I recently heard that pickles were a favorite store item at one school! 
  9. Phone Wallets & Pop Sockets
  10. Fun Erasers
  11. Sports Balls (soccer, baseball, etc.) – Pro Tip: Allow students to keep these in your classroom with their name on it and take it out for recess!
  12. Small $5 gift cards
  13. Magnets for Lockers
  14. Water Bottles
  15. Pencil Pouches
  16. Earbuds
  17. Small Board Games – Decks of cards or other games could be played during free time and are a great way to build friendship in the classroom.
  18. Fidget Toys – Small pop fidget toys in different shapes are always popular!
  19. Mini Puzzles Sudoku books and activity books were a big hit with my 8th graders!
Student-Led Store

Reward Ideas for High School

Free Reward Ideas:

  1. Homework Pass
  2. Extra Credit Points
  3. Extended Assignment Deadline – Pro Tip: Make this for 1-2 weeks, no questions asked, on certain assignments!
  4. Skip a Quiz Pass
  5. Priority Seating
  6. Organize a Class Event – Have a student be able to pick the next time you do a fun Friday or movie day.
  7. Positive Note Home
  8. Choose a Classroom Activity
  9. Dress Down Day Pass 
  10. Extra Study Time – this could also be extended to the whole class. A student of mine won this for the whole class for a test!
  11. Choose a Class Movie
  12. Library Pass
  13. Drop the Lowest Grade
  14. Skip the Line at Lunch
  15. Nature Walk for Class This was the number one reward that my students would want to win as a group prize!

Low Cost Reward Ideas:

  1. Gift Cards (e.g. iTunes, Starbucks, Fast food restaurants) – A lot of businesses will actually give you these for free or a discount to schools if you ask!
  2. Raffle Tickets Allow students to purchase raffle tickets for any high priced rewards, like the gift cards above!
  3. High-Quality Pens 
  4. Phone Accessories (e.g. Privacy screens, headphones, and portable chargers)
  5. School Dance Tickets – School dance tickets at my school were $5, but it was a huge deal when I gave 5 away for a behavior incentive!
  6. Water Bottles
  7. Personalized or School Spirit T-Shirts 
  8. Bluetooth Speakers
  9. Lunch on the Teacher – Buy students lunch from their favorite local restaurant! 
  10. Art Supplies
  11. Snacks (e.g., chips, candy, Cup of Noodles )
  12. Sunglasses or Fan Misters  
  13. Baseball Caps (e.g. school merchandise or local sports team)
  14. Locker Accessories (magnets, magnetic organizers etc.)
  15. Cosmetic Items (e.g., lip balm, hand sanitizer)

The Key to Effective Student Rewards

The best way to create an engaging school store that motivates your students is to ask your students! They're the experts on what excites them and will help you tailor your token economy or PBIS rewards for maximum impact. But in the meantime, we're here with inspiration to get you started. If you have any other hot-ticket items that aren't on our list, we'd love to hear about them!

Go Digital with Your School Store

Ready to ditch the paper school bucks and simplify your reward system? ClassBank's digital school store makes it easy to motivate students and manage rewards. Students earn, save, and spend virtual currency, learning valuable money management skills along the way.

Digital School Store

Check out The Essential Guide to Setting up your School Store and schedule a demo to learn more!

Image Sources: 
1, WNEP, Solomon-Plains Elementary, Accessed via https://www.wnep.com/article/news/local/luzerne-county/student-run-store-teaches-life-skills-solomon-plains-wolfack-warehouse/523-7808c355-a5a3-4810-814d-49a99b010099
2. Fillmore Unified School District, Accessed via https://www.blog.fillmoreusd.org/sierra-high-school-warriors-blog/2022/9/15/crocs-amp-socks-day
3. Cedar Park Middle School, Accessed via https://www.cedarparkptc.org/news/2018/9/19/student-store-and-pack-store-now-open-for-business